HomeOddities & CuriositiesPhoto GalleryAuctionsAuction PreviewEstate Sales

Finders Keepers ® 2789 Middle Country Road, Lake Grove, NY 11755   (631) 737-1400

​                                                   The Best Thrift Shop on Long Island, NY
Finders Keepers 
2789 Middle Country Road
Lake Grove, NY 11755

1/2 Mile East of Smith Haven Mall
Across from The Good Steer Restaurant


Monday - 12pm - 7pm
Tuesday - 10am - 7pm
Wednesday - 10am - 7pm
Thursday - 10am - 7pm
Friday - 10am - 7pm
 Saturday - 10am - 7pm
Sunday - 10am - 5pm

We are open most Holidays
Friend request us on Facebook to keep up with the latest Finders Keepers happenings such as:
 New Arrivals, Ebay Listings, Auction Updates and More!
Amazing Summer
Deals with Fast
Changing Inventory !!!
Follow us on Instagram @finderskeeperslakegrove OR follow Pico our store mascot @PicothePomeranian
Finders Keepers is a rare and unique shop. You will not find any other store like this anywhere on Long Island. We have a huge collection of vintage items, collectibles, antiques & oddities at thrift shop prices. 
Stop by and see what everybody 
is talking about.
Stop by for a unique 
  shopping experience!
Contact Us
Interested in learning more about our shop?
Moving? Downsizing? Need to get rid of clutter? 
Have a Finders Keepers Estate Sale!
Click here for Upcoming Estate Sales!!!
20% Off
Entire Oddities
Section !!!
Subscribe to our e-mail list to get updates on Auctions
and Sales !!!
Email Marketing You Can Trust
Earn extra cash!!!
Let us pick thru your attic, basement or garage !!!