HomeOddities & CuriositiesPhoto GalleryAuctionsAuction PreviewEstate Sales

Finders Keepers ® 2789 Middle Country Road, Lake Grove, NY 11755   (631) 737-1400

​                                                   The Best Thrift Shop on Long Island, NY
Finders Keepers 
2789 Middle Country Road
Lake Grove, NY 11755

1/2 Mile East of Smith Haven Mall
Across from The Good Steer Restaurant


Monday - 12pm - 7pm
Tuesday - 10am - 7pm
Wednesday - 10am - 7pm
Thursday - 10am - 7pm
Friday - 10am - 7pm
 Saturday - 10am - 7pm
Sunday - 10am - 5pm

We are open most Holidays
Friend request us on Facebook to keep up with the latest Finders Keepers happenings such as:
 New Arrivals, Ebay Listings, Auction Updates and More!
3 Day Weekend Sale
Saturday, Sunday
& Monday
1-15 thru 1-18
Finders Keepers is a rare and unique shop. You will not find any other store like this anywhere on Long Island. We have a huge collection of vintage items, collectibles, antiques & oddities at thrift shop prices. 
Stop by and see what everybody 
is talking about.
Stop by for a unique 
  shopping experience!
Contact Us
Interested in learning more about our shop?
Moving? Downsizing? Need to get rid of clutter? 
Have a Finders Keepers Estate Sale!
Click here for Upcoming Estate Sales!!!
Super Bowl Party
for your Man Cave
Shop Today !
Subscribe to our e-mail list to get updates on Auctions
and Sales !!!
Email Marketing You Can Trust
Earn extra cash!!!
Let us pick thru your attic, basement or garage !!!

Erin C.
Port Jefferson, NY
0 friends
3 reviews
Share review
Send message
Follow Erin C.
Having driven by the sign for this shop dozens of times I finally decided to stop and check it out. I'm so glad I did and being a huge fan of antique stores and thrift stores, why I never stopped before is beyond me. It is sheer awesomeness. Brian, the owner, is a really nice guy. He's also an artist and you can find his original creations all over the shop. I do dig the doll lamps- very creepy going to come to life in the middle of the night and try to take you out and cool. 

You really need to carve out some time in your day to check this place out properly. It's not a super huge shop but it's large enough and filled to the brim with all sorts of treasures. Like any thrift or antique store, there is a lot to look at! The prices are really reasonable as well. They are more Pennsylvania antique mall prices than Long Island prices. The store is organized and features different zones where specific items can be found. Lots of trading cards, sci-fi action figures, stuff like that. My new go-to source for baseball cards for my nephew. I can't imagine going anywhere else at this point. The selection is insane! He has a very random selection of very random things - if you're ever looking for the perfect random gift for someone, this is a great place to find it. Seriously. The bone from a Raccoon's little buddy? He's got it. 

He also has auctions once a month and since the inventory changes so often, you just never know what cool thing you're going to find. I really highly recommend stopping by and checking this place out. I'm super glad I finally did, it's about time we have a cool store like this around here! He also buys items, depending on what it is of course. Always good to know.